Reforming School Food: Structure, Agency, And The Meaning Of Change
This dissertation examines school food reform from the perspective of actors who are directly implicated and participate most in its processes: school food service directors, food service staff, and students. School food reform has become a popular issue in the United States, particularly since the 2004 Child Nutrition and WIC Reauthorization Act required every school district in the country to develop a School Wellness Policy for promoting student health and physical activity. These policies were symbolic of larger national concerns about childhood health and wellness and grounded in the belief that schools are a critical site for addressing adolescent health. This research asks what school food reform means to actors closest to the center of change, how they interpret their role in this process, and what this means for reform prospects. In answering these questions, this study investigates how structural forces shaping school food from above and on-the-ground realities from below converge at the level of central actors who serve as shock absorbers of the contradictory forces in the process of school food reform. The analytical chapters in this dissertation focus on actors at the center of making change happen in the school food environment and the conflicts they experience due to differences between expectations from above and below. In chapter iii four, I examine the role conflict of food service directors as they reconcile the conflicts inherent in directing a program that is intended to improve childhood health and nutrition yet must be financially self-sustaining. In chapter five, I explore the role of food service staff, or "lunch ladies." In particular I examine how the "emotional labor" and technical labor that staff perform interact to ultimately align their interests with students, who are resistant to change for the most part. In chapter six, I focus on students and how their role as "consumer in the marketplace" has come to supersede their role as "student in the school," and how this is a result of the tendency in mainstream education to ignore the potential for school lunch to be an integral part of the school day. iv