Polarization in American School Board Elections: Causes, Consequences, and Analytical Challenges
Access to this document is restricted. Some items have been embargoed at the request of the author, but will be made publicly available after the "No Access Until" date.
During the embargo period, you may request access to the item by clicking the link to the restricted file(s) and completing the request form. If we have contact information for a Cornell author, we will contact the author and request permission to provide access. If we do not have contact information for a Cornell author, or the author denies or does not respond to our inquiry, we will not be able to provide access. For more information, review our policies for restricted content.
This dissertation examines the politicization of school board governance in the United States following the COVID-19 pandemic. Historically, school board elections attracted little attention and low participation. Since 2021, however, they have become more visible and contested. Disputes over school closures and curriculum coincided with increased public engagement, activism, and sharper ideological conflict, altering both school board elections and governance.The first essay studies whether the parental rights movement is driven by concerns about student outcomes or by political forces. Using original data on school board races, I find that local partisan conditions are the strongest predictors of both candidate entry and electoral success. Support for Donald Trump, competitive local politics, and the presence of racial justice protests are more closely associated with these outcomes than measures of academic performance or pandemic policy. The results indicate that the movement reflects broader partisan conflict rather than dissatisfaction with school performance. The second essay examines whether politicized school board elections lead families to leave public school districts. Using a regression discontinuity design, I find no overall effect on public school enrollment. However, responses vary across contexts. In urban districts, parental rights victories reduce public school enrollment and increase charter attendance. Among higher-income Black households, these victories are associated with declines in Black student enrollment. These patterns suggest that exit is limited but concentrated among groups with greater ability or motivation to respond. The third essay presents a method for building datasets from decentralized online sources using a combination of large language models and human review. I develop this approach to address the limits of manual collection, web scraping, and APIs by enabling flexible data extraction across varied sources. Validation shows that fully automated methods introduce classification errors, while human oversight improves accuracy. The framework offers a scalable approach to collecting complex online data. In this dissertation, I show that school board politicization is driven by partisan dynamics, has uneven local effects, and can be studied using new data methods. Through the study of school board elections, I highlight how national political conflict reshapes local governance, with consequences that vary across communities.