The S2 subunit of the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) spike is highly conserved across coronavirus strains and therefore is a potential pan-coronavirus vaccine target. However, antibodies targeting this region are typically non-neutralizing. We report herein that S2-targeting antibodies from patients who recovered from SARS-CoV-2 infection bound only closely related sarbecovirus subgenus strains and, like most known S2 antibodies, none of these were neutralizing. In contrast, first-exposure, severe acutely infected COVID-19 patients predominantly induced back-boosted antibody-secreting cells imprinted against past common cold coronavirus strain OC43 that were cross-reactive to as many as five subgenera of betacoronavirus strains and gave rise to antibodies that were neutralizing and protective. The antibodies targeted two different sites: one defined by competition with stem helix antibodies, and the second to an underdescribed epitope at the apex of S2. These findings suggest that S2-targeted vaccines could strategically exploit controlled OC43 priming followed by SARS-CoV-2 boosting to enhance the breadth and quality of protective antibody responses.