Essays on the Political Participation and Views of Immigrant-origin Citizens in Germany
Residents with a migration history make up around 14 percent of all residents in OECD countries, with numbers increasing quickly. While these numbers seem numerically small, these residents potentially represent an important component of the electorate in these countries - large enough to swing elections. Despite their electoral potential, their political participation is not well understood and is far from equal. As a subset of residents with a migration background, non-citizens (residents that do not have the citizenship of the country in which they reside) make up approximately 10 percent of residents in European countries. 1 In most countries this means that these non-citizen residents do not have voting rights on the national level and are politically disenfranchised. While excluding more than 10 percent of permanent residents from formal political participation already raises normative questions about the quality and legitimacy of German democracy, I argue in this dissertation that these increasing shares of disenfranchised noncitizen residents who are not eligible to vote in national elections have massive implications and spill-overs for formal political participation for other citizens as well - in particular for immigrant-origin citizens. The overarching question in this thesis is as follows: is the political participation of immigrant-origin citizens in a conventional Western democratic setting truly democratic and equal? How does the (politically) conscious legal exclusion of large shares of immigrants without citizenship (as in non-citizens without the right to vote) from the electorate relate to political participation, representation, and political views for all eligible voters in general - regardless of their migration background? And how does this formal exclusion relate to immigrant-origin citizens who, by definition, are a subset of immigrant-origin residents but are eligible to vote? How do citizens contextualized in a local and social setting where legal exclusion from voting is the norm participate politicall themselves? I attempt to shed light on these questions by looking at administrative, voting, and public opinion data in Germany from 1950 to 2020. First, I test if local contextualization matters for political participation. Second, I test if social contextualization matters using contemporary data. Third, I test if a more favorable, historical policy environment in Germany led to different results – and I find that it did. In the second chapter, the main question is, how does local contextualization matter for political participation? I use high spatial resolution German public opinion and administrative election data to show that there is a strong negative relationship between neighborhoods/municipalities with a large share of non-citizens and a reduction of voter turn-out in national elections. This relationship is negative and strong for both immigrant-origin citizens and autochthonous citizens.2 In the third chapter, I attempt to zoom in on the social contextualization of voting. I use German panel data to show that citizens that have non-citizen peers in their peer group tend to report voting less in national elections than citizens without these direct non-citizen links. In chapter four, I test whether a more favorable policy environment could have led to different outcomes in Germany. I use a historical case of expellees who were forced migrants from former East German territories who fled to Germany after World War II. They received full citizenship and voting rights shortly after their arrival in Germany between 1945 and 1953. Despite substantial exposure to social and political discrimination, they did not show the same patterns as discovered in chapter 2 and 3. After 10 years or so, their political participation was almost indistinguishable from other German citizens. This implies that social and political acceptance in combination with a favorable policy environment (direct access to citizenship and voting rights) matters a lot for the political participation of migrants.