Islam and Art in the Makings of the Modern in Indonesia
Through attending to the multiple reinterpretations, experiences, and conflicting responses from artists and intellectuals to the questions of what it means to be modern and Muslim, this dissertation expands and complicates the genealogies of “modernism” and “Islam” in the context of Indonesia. Genealogy matters significantly in my research as it examines the works of four artists who belonged to different generations of students trained at the colonial art training institution in Bandung that is known today as the Faculty of Art and Design, Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB – Bandung Institute of Technology). These artists are Ahmad Sadali (1924-1987, Garut, Indonesia), A.D. Pirous (b. 1932, Meulaboh, Indonesia), Haryadi Suadi (1938-2016, Cirebon, Indonesia) and Arahmaiani (b. 1961, Bandung, Indonesia). Each artwork by Sadali, Pirous, Haryadi, and Arahmaiani responds to and opposes existing aesthetic conventions using various languages of representation to challenge doctrine, authority, and specific moral teachings. I approach the term “modern” and “Islamic” as propositions and challenges rather than fixed but vague categories. I suggest that these artworks construct and communicate different values, identities, and desires related to discourses of modernism, Islamic authenticity, and proper religiosity. My analysis of the absences of the question of Islam and Islamic religiosity in the historiography of Indonesian and Southeast Asian modern and contemporary art challenges the secular narratives of the historiography of modern and contemporary art in Indonesia. At the same time, it also attends to the overlooked importance and marginalized position of Southeast Asia and Southeast Asian art in the disciplines of Islamic art history and Islamic Studies. The dissertation narrates the stories of modernity that carefully consider both the artists’ critical negotiations with global modernism and global Islam and the particular experiences of Islam and being Muslim in Indonesia.