Recovery of Real Estate Returns for Portfolio Allocation
Corgel, John B.; deRoos, Jan A.
Appraisal-based return indexes may not approximate the true real estate return distributions because of understated return volatility. Recovery of returns from reported, appraisal-based returns may be possible by evoking models to correct for appraisal-based smoothing of the second moment. Because recovery intentionally alters the volatility of the reported return distribution and the correlations among assets in the portfolio, the weights to real estate are likely affected. Our examination of the portfolio implications of altering the return distribution indicates that weights may be quite sensitive to the effects of recovery across a reasonable range of correlation regimes. A comparative analysis of several recovery models reveals that all models achieve the objective of inflating the volatility of reported returns. However, the models also change the mean of the return distribution, which either counteracts or magnifies the effect of the volatility change on allocations. These findings bring into question the applicability of recovery models in their current form.
return indexes; appraisal smoothing; portfolio allocation
Required Publisher Statement: © Springer. Final version published as: Corgel, J. B., & deRoos, J. A. (1999). Recovery of real estate returns for portfolio allocation. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 18(3), 279-296. doi: 10.1023/A:1007728900308Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.