Brand Rights and Hotel Management Agreements: Lessons from Ritz-Carlton Bali’s Lawsuit against the Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company
Dev, Chekitan S.; Thomas, John H.; Buschman, John D.; Anderson, Eric
In this article, the authors consider the managerial implications of a recent lawsuit, P. T. Karang Mas Sejahtera v. The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company, LLC, in which a jury found for the plaintiff, the owner of the Ritz-Carlton Bali Resort and Spa, against the defendant, The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company, LLC. Ritz-Carlton’s parent company, Marriott International, had previously formed a partnership with Bulgari S.p.A., the Italian luxury jewelry and accessories firm, to create Bulgari Hotels and Resorts, a new ultraexclusive line of luxury hotels. The first two Bulgari properties opened in Milan and Bali. Soon after the Bali project was announced, P. T. Karang Mas Sejahtera (KMS) sued Ritz-Carlton for breach of agreement. The authors show that this and other recent court decisions situate hotel management agreements squarely under agency law. Within the framework of agency law, an agent owes specific fiduciary duties to a principal that supersede contractual terms and a principal has a nearly absolute right to terminate such a agreement. In the Bali case, the violated duties included a duty not to compete with or assist the competitors of a property being managed under agreements within that property’s competitive market set. The authors argue that, as a consequence of these legal decisions, issues pertaining to brand rights and management agreements have been clarified. In this article, the authors outline these brand rights issues, review these precedent-setting legal cases, explain why Ritz-Carlton lost the suit to KMS, and draw several lessons pertaining to hotel management.
brand rights; hotel management agreements; hotel brand licensing; hotel litigation; international hotels; Marriott; Ritz-Carlton; Bugari; Bali
Required Publisher Statement: © Cornell University. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Enz, Cathy A.; Verma, Rohit; Walsh, Kate; Kimes, Sheryl E.; Siguaw, Judy D.B.A. (2010-08-01)This final set of hospitality innovators presents vignettes and brief descriptions of some 23 innovations. While the innovation does not have to be the first or best, in many cases the practices described are either unique ...
Corgel, John B.; Woodworth, R. Mark (2012-11-01)Despite tepid economic indicators, the demand for hotel rooms in the United States has surged since the depths of the great recession in 2009. Bucking all apparent economic trends, lodging has been a leading industry during ...