An odyssey through sight, sound, and touch: Toward a perceptual theory of implicit statistical learning
In order to steer through a world characterized by a complex mixture of variability and structure, organisms rely upon implicit statistical learning, the capability to extract probabalistic patterns occurring in environmental stimuli. Although statistical learning has been found to occur across a myriad of domains, there has been little investigation into the effect that sense modality and other stimulus attributes may have on learning. In a series of experiments, I investigate to what extent implicit statistical learning is constrained and influenced by the nature of the input in which the statistical regularities occur. All experiments have in common the use of artificial grammar learning methodology, where adult participants are incidentally exposed to statistically-governed patterns and then are tested on their ability to apply their acquired knowledge to novel instances. Chapter 2 presents two experiments that compared learning across touch, vision, and audition, producing evidence for modality constraints. Specifically, the auditory modality displayed a quantitative learning advantage compared to vision and touch; additionally, each sense modality was more or less attuned to specific aspects of the input. Chapter 3 describes an experiment that further explored modality constraints by manipulating both the presentation format (temporal, spatial, or spatiotemporal) and presentation rate for visual and auditory material. Consistent with a modality-constrained view of learning, vision and audition were best at encoding spatial and temporal regularities, respectively. Finally, using a novel cross-over design, Chapter 4 presents three experiments that pitted abstract, amodal processing against stimulus-specific learning and found that statistical learning is mediated to a greater extent by stimulus-specific, not abstract, representations. Taken together, the results from these experiments suggest that statistical learning inherently involves learning mechanisms that are heavily influenced by the perceptual and sensory characteristics of the stimuli. I argue that a full understanding of statistical learning -- and likely other aspects of language and cognition will come only by specifying the role played by the senses. I conclude with a proposal for a perceptual, modality-constrained view of implicit statistical learning framed within the context of cognition as a whole.
Morten H. Christiansen, Michael Owren, Elizabeth Regan, Michael Spivey
American Psychological Association
artificial grammar learning; statistical learning; implicit learning; tactile learning; modality effects
Previously Published As
Conway, C.M. & Christiansen, M.H. (2005). Modality-constrained statistical learning of tactile, visual, and auditory sequences. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 31, 24-39.
dissertation or thesis
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
The Form Of Learning Is The Learning Of Forms: Models Of Socialist Aesthetic Education In Gorky, Hacks, And MüLler Pickle, Sarah (2014-01-27)Most readers of politically committed literature dismiss it either because they disagree with the content presented in it or because its ostensibly crass instrumentalization of art in the service of a socialist program ...
Outside The Machine Learning Blackbox: Supporting Analysts Before And After The Learning Algorithm Munson, Miles (2010-08-05)Applying machine learning to real problems is non-trivial because many important steps are needed to prepare for learning and to interpret the results after learning. This dissertation investigates four problems that arise ...
Online Learning Algorithms For Sequence Prediction, Importance Weighted Classification, And Active Learning Karampatziakis, Nikolaos (2012-08-20)This thesis studies three problems in online learning. For all the problems the proposed solutions are simple yet non-trivial adaptations of existing online machine learning algorithms. For the task of sequential prediction, ...