Cornell University
Library
Cornell UniversityLibrary

eCommons

Help
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Cornell SC Johnson College of Business
  3. Cornell Peter and Stephanie Nolan School of Hotel Administration
  4. School of Hotel Administration Collection
  5. SHA Articles and Chapters
  6. The Mixed Motive Instruction: Did the Supreme Court Make Discrimination Cases Unwinnable for Employers?

The Mixed Motive Instruction: Did the Supreme Court Make Discrimination Cases Unwinnable for Employers?

File(s)
Sherwyn15_The_Mixed_Motive_Instruction.pdf (258.9 KB)
Permanent Link(s)
https://hdl.handle.net/1813/71799
Collections
SHA Articles and Chapters
Author
Sherwyn, David
Wagner, Paul
Baumgarten, Joe
Abstract

Following a 2003 U.S. Supreme Court decision, employers face the prospect of fighting employment discrimination cases that they cannot afford to win. A decision involving Caesars Palace held that based on a 1991 federal statute, a complaining employee need not give direct evidence of discrimination as part of the complaint. This is a change in the treatment formerly given to the so-called mixed motive concept, in which a personnel decision regarding an employee who is part of a protected class may be motivated by both legitimate business considerations and discrimination. In addition to apparently shifting the burden of proof, the federal law provides for jury trials in discrimination complaints. Because such trials involve considerable legal expense, employers who choose to litigate such cases may “win” but be impoverished by the resulting legal bills. The concern in such a situation is that employers may find themselves subject to inappropriate discrimination suits.

Date Issued
2004-05-01
Keywords
employment discrimination
•
Civil Rights Law of 1991
•
Caesars Palace
•
burden of proof
•
mixed motive instruction
Rights
Required Publisher Statement: © Cornell University. Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.
Type
article

Site Statistics | Help

About eCommons | Policies | Terms of use | Contact Us

copyright © 2002-2026 Cornell University Library | Privacy | Web Accessibility Assistance